50% Off Selected Impact Range | Auto Apply
+ 35% Off Everything Else | Use Code: FUEL35
TAKE EXTRA 5% OFF ON APP
SHOP NOW

Protein Cookie

Customer Reviews

Protein Cookie Customer Reviews

USD
Protein Cookie
Overall Rating : 4.45 / 5 (374 Reviews)
  • 234 5 star reviews
  • 96 4 star reviews
  • 30 3 star reviews
  • 7 2 star reviews
  • 7 1 star reviews
4.45 / 5 (374 Reviews)
  • 234 5 star reviews
  • 96 4 star reviews
  • 30 3 star reviews
  • 7 2 star reviews
  • 7 1 star reviews

Where reviews refer to foods or cosmetic products, results may vary from person to person. Customer reviews are independent and do not represent the views of The Hut Group.

Protein Cookie

4
Overall:

Purchased a box at a show and loved them! So much protein in one snack with great flavor goes very well with a cup of mud! I just purchased 3 boxes to last me a while!!
Goes Well With:
Coffee or green tea

Was this helpful?

Protein cookie

4
Overall:

I try bouth white and chocolate.... did not like the white almond an will not order again. The chocolate is pretty good. Am sure there's people that will go with the white since the dont like chocolate but trust... the white don't taste good at all.

Was this helpful?

Great tasting cookie with great macros!

5
Overall:

I have nothing but great things to say about these protein cookies. I've tried each flavor and I can say that the "double chocolate" is tied with the white chocolate flavor for my favorite. The orange flavored cookie is quite good but how you enjoy it will depend person to person. I liked the flavor but I could see others not liking it depending on their tastes. The only complaint I have is not with the cookie itself but with MyProtein. In my most recent order I purchased one box of double chocolate and one box of white chocolate cookies. Instead of receiving one of each kind, I received two boxes of the white chocolate flavor. The cookies taste great but I would have preferred to have received what I specifically ordered. Thanks and great cookies!
Goes Well With:
On its own/milk/coffee

Was this helpful?

Protein cookies, need I say more?

4
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

Only worthwhile flavor is Double Chocolate. On their own they are ok, but if you throw em in the microwave for 15-20 seconds they become magical. Taste greatly improves with the melted chocolate chips. Highly recommend these!

Was this helpful?

Awesome product

5
Overall:

Love these cookies. They're so convenient and have the best nutritional profile for a protein food that I've ever seen (literally 50% protein by weight). Little try, but always soft. Will definitely repurchase

Was this helpful?

THE Perfect protein cookie

5
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

I can't believe I went so long without these cookies. I've tried a lot of the ones out there...Lenny and Larry's, Buffbake, Nashua, and a few others. While all were good tasting (some better than others), I had yet to find a cookie that was easy to fit the WHOLE cookie into my daily macros and be full and satisfied afterwards. I don't know what it is about My Protein Cookies, but they are all of those things. They check all of the boxes. Perfect size (not too big not too small), the nutrition facts are for the entire cookie (very convenient and simple), and the macros are great for when you need more protein than carbs. And the taste is great, of course. First tried while in vegas and they were sold at a gym I went to, and I had to order 2 boxes as soon as I got home. I love these cookies and can't wait to try the chocolate mint and chocolate orange. Thank you for making the best protein cookie on the market!
Goes Well With:
Dollop gourmet frosting, Ds natural fluff butter, any nut spread or protein spread, Sweetened nonfat greek yogurt frosting (homemade), dipped in almond milk, eaten with Halo top ice cream, the list goes on!

Was this helpful?

Double chocolate

4
Overall:

Good tasting cookie. Best if microwaved for 12 sec.

Was this helpful?

WAAAAAYYYYY to sweet

3
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

Please tone down the sweetness in these cookies. I have tried this one and the double chocolate chip and they are far too sweet. I prefer the Lenny and Larry's brand.

Was this helpful?

Protein cookies

5
Overall:

These cookies taste great, and are perfect to just grab and go when in a pinch

Was this helpful?

Good source of protein

5
Overall:

They taste great and have lots of protein. Only thing is that the calorie count is kinda high ( I've seen worse tho) wish it was lower in calories especially for someone who is on a calorie deficit, and especially they taste so good. It does have a good balance of carbs to protein and comes in several flavors. Will definitely buy again and again.
Goes Well With:
Milk.

Was this helpful?