HOLIDAY HAUL
TAKE UP TO 50% OFF EVERYTHING
+ EXTRA 10% OFF WITH CODE: HOLIDAY10
TAKE AN ADDITONAL +5% ON THE APP
SHOP NOW

Protein Cookie

Customer Reviews

Protein Cookie Customer Reviews

USD
Protein Cookie
Overall Rating : 4.45 / 5 (374 Reviews)
  • 234 5 star reviews
  • 96 4 star reviews
  • 30 3 star reviews
  • 7 2 star reviews
  • 7 1 star reviews
4.45 / 5 (374 Reviews)
  • 234 5 star reviews
  • 96 4 star reviews
  • 30 3 star reviews
  • 7 2 star reviews
  • 7 1 star reviews

Where reviews refer to foods or cosmetic products, results may vary from person to person. Customer reviews are independent and do not represent the views of The Hut Group.

Best overall cookie!

4
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

These hands-down have the best macros of any protein cookie on the market. The taste is a little off, but that's to be expected. I find that microwaving them for about 20 seconds enhances the flavor significantly. I can only speak for the White Almond Chocolate flavor, however. I purchased some of the Orange Chocolate ones, but I assume they were old stock as when they arrive they were expired. My money was promptly refunded, which is admirable, but I really wish the stock of these cookies was more consistent. A lot of reviewers seem to like the Double Chocolate flavor; it seems to have been out of stock for months though. Overall, a very macro-friendly cookie and an excellent bang for your buck. Highly recommend.
Goes Well With:
Milk/20 seconds in the microwave

Was this helpful?

fine protein desserts

4
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

I've tried 3 flavors of these cookies: Oatmeal Raisin, Cookies & Cream, and White Vanilla. Unfortunately never got my hands on the double chocolate that the other reviewers are raving about. The Oatmeal Raisin & White Vanilla are pretty good - the consistency is more cookie-like in these flavors. Cookies & Cream was really tough and not very flavorful, so I save that one for when I'm too hungry to care. Microwaving the Oatmeal Raisin flavor comes out with pretty good results. Taste of the flavors is not as good as something like Quest bars, but these have better value as far as protein/price goes.
Goes Well With:
20 seconds in the microwave

Was this helpful?

Double Chocolate!!

5
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

Please bring back the double-chocolate chip and keep all the flavors in stock!! There aren't any other cookies like this in the US that I've found, and it sucks that the inventory is so spotty.

Was this helpful?

Double Chocolate!!!!!!!

4
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

Where has the double chocolate flavor gone? It's been months! Other regions not only have this flavor, but they also have different types of snacks that the US store simply doesn't. These were my defacto snack and sometimes lunch replacement.
Goes Well With:
Almond milk or coffee.

Was this helpful?

My preciousssss

4
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

My precioussssss!! I need these cookies back please! In double chocolate! Not this almond flavor. I noticed the price increase and I don't even care! Just ginmie back my daily snack! Pleaseeeee ❤❤❤
Goes Well With:
All the things!

Was this helpful?

Please

5
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

We need our double chocolate chip back, please
Goes Well With:
More double chocolate brownies

Was this helpful?

Location issue

5
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

The protein cookies are finally back in stock! I was super eager to purchase the cookies, but then ran into a situation where it says they won't deliver to my location. I haven't had a problem in the past. I can purchase other items with no issues at all. Is anyone else having this issue? Please help resolve it as soon as possible, there is no other cookie quite like this one.
Goes Well With:
Anytime throughout the day.

Was this helpful?

Bring them back, please

5
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

These have been out of stock for a few weeks, now and it appears that the price has been increased as well. Please bring them back at a reasonable price, and I will stock up with cases!

Was this helpful?

We're never getting Double Chocolate Chip

5
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

It's never coming back is it. Everyday is a disappointment.

Was this helpful?

Smell is so bad

1
Overall:

These cookies taste like they are rotten and gone bad. Just imagine you eat a rotten chicken breast. Same bad smell. The taste is actually good but I believe those are gone bad and they sell them nevertheless by labeling them again with new expiry date. Otherwise there could not be another explanation of this rotten smell. Unbearable to be honest.
Goes Well With:
Sorry

Was this helpful?

Protein Cookie Customer Reviews

USD
Protein Cookie

Quantity:

( 0 item is in your cart items are in your cart )