You have added

Sorry, there seems to have been an error. Please try again.

Qty:

Subtotal: ( items in your basket)

Baked Cookie

Customer Reviews

Baked Cookie

Baked Cookie Customer Reviews

USD
2.0

16 Reviews

5 7
4 0
3 0
2 1
1 8

Qty:

Item limited to max quantity of

( item is in your basket items are in your basket )

2.0

16 Reviews

5 7
4 0
3 0
2 1
1 8

Where reviews refer to foods or cosmetic products, results may vary from person to person. Customer reviews are independent and do not represent the views of The Hut Group.

New recipe is terrible

1
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

The new recipe is terrible. The nutrition is awful. You'd be better off eating some regular cookies. I asked their customer service why this was changed, and they claimed that this is a cookie for bulking. Low protein, high sugar. The new recipe for building muscle...apparently.
Goes Well With:
A garbage can

Was this helpful?

Yes (2) No (0)
Report this review

BRING BACK THE OLD COOKIES

1
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

The previous cookies were SO good both nutritionally and in taste. I want those back. This has waaaayyy too much sugar and in my opinion also makes the taste less good.

Was this helpful?

Yes (8) No (0)
Report this review

Major Misstep

1
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

Same as other reviewers, taste is fine, but nutritionally terrible. More sugar than protein, half the protein than previously. BRING BACK THE ORIGINAL RECIPE.

Was this helpful?

Yes (8) No (0)
Report this review

BRING BACK THE OLD RECIPE

1
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

These are not good nutritionally when you compare with the old cookie or the protein brownies. Bring back the old products.

Was this helpful?

Yes (11) No (0)
Report this review

Great Protein Cookie

5
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

These cookies are amazing. Super chocolatey and a nice amount of calories of your a little low for the day. I like to keep them in the fridge to make them a bit firmer. Highly recommended.
Goes Well With:
Soy Milk, Almond Milk, really any kind of milk that you prefer.

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (7)
Report this review

not the 37g anymore? :(

1

I was a faithful customer due to the previous 37g cookies - the macros on those were nuts! Now that they're not available, I'm taking my business elsewhere. Sorry!

Was this helpful?

Yes (21) No (0)
Report this review

Major Misstep

1
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

These used to be my go to snack between meals. They used to have nearly 40g of protein and less than 10g sugar. All they did with this terrible new recipe is add a bunch of fats and sugar in place of the protein! If someone wanted a cookie with slightly higher protein content than average, they would just go to the health food section of the grocery store. That’s not why we shop at MyProtein. We want the best products for our fitness goals. That’s NOT what this is. Cut your losses and drop this subpar product and bring back the old recipe!

Most Helpful Reviewer

Was this helpful?

Yes (32) No (0)
Report this review

just a cookie.

1
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

I liked having a high protein option. Like others have said, this is basically just a regular cookie that is slightly healthier than normal.

Was this helpful?

Yes (13) No (0)
Report this review

High carb, high calorie, tastes great

2
Overall:

These cookies taste excellent, but the nutrition profile is not consistent with other products from MyProtein. You can get cookies with similar taste and nutrition profiles from Lenny and Larry and similar brands, and those are available cheaper and in more varieties with similar taste. I hope that MyProtein brings back the high protein (37 gram) variant in White Chocolare Almond and Rocky Road.

Was this helpful?

Yes (12) No (0)
Report this review

Honestly Superb

5
Overall:
Mixability:
Taste:
Effectiveness:

Right off the bat I want to say that while the macros aren't the best in general it still is VERY FAIR as a decent macro treat & compares super well to the competition. Couldn't even tell that these cookies had that much protein in them because they tasted so good. Personally, I really enjoy them. It's a better alternative to a brownie or chips imo, so that's how I think of it. Definitely need to get more soon!
Goes Well With:
Any other of the myprotein snacks. They're all good. But this works well alone too as just an on the go treat!

Was this helpful?

Yes (0) No (10)
Report this review

Back to top